Charlottesville Photographer Matt Rosenberg Threatens Spicy Bear Media and Demands $2,500
Update 8:30PM 11/19/2008 - We removed the thumbnails from the posts and our server.
It’s never fun being involved in potential lawsuits, but we just got a letter from Charlottesville photographer Matt Rosenberg who works for the Daily Progress. In this letter, Matt’s attorney alleges that we have:
not responded to Matthew Rosenberg’s facsimile letter of September 15, 2008, he has retained this firm to represent him in the matter of Spicy Bear Media’s infringement of his copyright.
We never received any facsimile letter from Matt or any other contact before this letter.
The attorney didn’t even send a copy of this alleged “sent facsimile.” Also, we didn’t post any “pictures;” as you can see they are low-resolution thumbnails. Oh, and there is nothing in this letter about how using the thumbnails actually harmed you or caused damages. Using thumbnails of pictures is “fair use.” Read about it here or here.
Now his attorney is demanding $2,500 for use of the two little thumbnails we used in Garage posts (1 and 2). I called Matt and he told me he couldn’t provide any confirmation that he actually sent us the facsimile letter. Matt could have just contacted me via phone, email, in comments or on the contact form from the site and resolved this issue, but he didn’t and hired an attorney to threaten us. Indeed, Matt has every opportunity to contact us about the thumbnail, but didn’t.
As far as I’m concerned this is a predatory practice and forces us to either (1) settle with him to avoid a potential lawsuit or (2) to spend a lot more than $2,500 defending ourselves in a lawsuit. We’re still figuring out what to do. In the past, we’ve always responded to photographers or other media holders about any issues, but it’s a little scary to think that these sort of predatory practices can work for websites. Matt, maybe you should sue Google, too, because they have your big pictures cached?
Oh, the fun of being a Spicy Bear! A copy of the letter from Matt’s lawyer is after the break…
Popularity: 32% [?]




